Monday, June 1, 2020

Conclusion – Employee motivation in Government / Semi - government Sector



Altogether by analyzing previous blog posts may confirm that motivation is an individual phenomenon that pushes individual performance nevertheless it is a private or government organization. Since this known as individualistic force, thus a one-size-fits-all approach to employee motivation does not work. Therefore managers need to identify the exact motivating factors of every individual and address them separately to enhance employee performance and maximize output (Re'em, 2011).
According to Luthans (1992), motivation defines as a process that starts from a need that energizes certain behavior, directs, and sustains that behavior towards to achieve a specific target. In summary can state as desires, determinations, and inducement. Most research has exposed that public sector employees are more intrinsically and less extrinsically motivated (Ristic, Selakovic, Qureshi, 2017).  As Rainey (1982) stated public sector employees frequently want to serve a sensible service to its citizens. Also, they want to have inspiration in public affairs. Furthermore, they cherish by assist to the public interest and contribute to achieving social justice.
It is adequately documented in the above writings that several thinkers have deliberate human behavior from different perceptions such as economic, psychological, and behavioral to understand what motivates people to do the things they do. In practice, they established several theories of motivation which some of them clearly explain in previous posts with examples. 
I take as a brief review of Abraham Maslow's Hierarchy of  Needs  Theory describes the grading of 5 needs known as physiological, security,  social, esteem, and self-actualize which are fulfilled by in order (Bawa, 2017). Secondly, Frederick Herzberg's two-factor theory that emphasizes the motivation-hygiene factors established by influencing Maslow's need theory (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017).
Thirdly, describe Douglas McGregor's theories X and Y. Theory X adopts that individuals are dishonorable, work-shy, and frequently to satisfy their lower-level requirements. Assumptions of Theory X linked with the base level of Maslow's hierarchy of needs theory. Even though this theory seems simple, they provide a platform to develop many more theories and identify the changing dynamic human (Zendage, 2018).
Finally, it refers to another theory that built upon Maslow's need theory known as Clayton Alderfer's ERG theory. Alderfer reduced levels and acceptable flexibility in the order of the needs thus stated that human needs should be satisfied simultaneously and not in any specific order (Govindaraju, 2018).
Moreover, research done by the staff of credit west banks illustrates the necessity of providing challenging jobs and personal growth opportunities for employees to obtain high performance in their workplace. Although employee recognition feels that their contribution makes a difference in company growth. While, the researchers have confirmed that the most effective and cost-efficient way to motivate employees is non-monetary rewards (Uzonna, 2013). But contrast to the above assumptions money becomes a vital motivating factor in government employees. Further, strategies such as team building, training, knowledge gathering, autonomy, pleasant working environment, identified as the most powerful motivational techniques in government employees.
However, this blog was concentrate on employee motivation in government and semi-government sector, since it is notable that there exists a strong relationship between employees' motivation and organizational effectiveness. Employees with high motivation are thought to have better work performance, and overall resulting in a better, more productive, and effective company performance (Nguyen, 2017). Creating a workplace with exceptional morale and motivated employees is a long-term plan thus, employees need to treat daily (Sabir, 2017). Though it is highly motivated and engaged individuals are a tremendous asset to any organization that achieves the goals and objectives of the organization as well as enjoying a competitive advantage in the industry in which the organization is operating (Fosu, 2016).

Reference

Alshmemri, M., Shahwan-Akl, L. and Maude, P., 2017. Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory. Life Science Journal, [online] 14(5). Available at: <https://www.lifesciencesite.com/lsj/life140517/03_32120lsj140517_12_16.pdf> [Accessed 18 May 2020].

Bawa, M. A.,2017. Employee Motivation and Productivity: A Review of Literature and Implications for Management Practice. International Journal of Economics, Commerce and Management. [online] V(12). Available at: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334263937_EMPLOYEE_MOTIVATION_AND_PRODUCTIVITY_A_REVIEW_OF_LITERATURE_AND_IMPLICATIONS_FOR_MANAGEMENT_PRACTICE> [Accessed 29 May 2020].

Fosu, F., 2016. The Impact Of Motivation, On Employee's Performance; The Case Of Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (Kath). Master ofBusiness Administrtion. Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology. [Accessed 25 May 2020].

Govindaraju, N., 2018. The role of traditional Motivation theories on employee retention. International Journal of Arts, Humanities and Management Studies, [online] 4(6), p.97. Available at: <http://ijahms.com/upcomingissue/12.06.2018.pdf> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Luthans F (1992). Organisational Behaviour, Mc Graw Hill. 2nd Ed. Irwin. Boston. [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Nguyen, M., 2017. The Impact Of Employees Motivation On Organizational Effectiveness. VAASAN AMMATTIKORKEAKOULU UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED SCIENCES. [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Rainey H.G., 1982, Reward Preferences among Public and Private Managers: In Search of the Service Ethic, “American Review of Public Administration”, 16(4). [Accessed 30 May 2020].

Re’em, Y., 2010. Motivating Public Sector Employees. [Online] (2). Available at: <https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/d364/8f7a3d4021ea00a92cf5f2d2f9cdcb643ca7.pdf> [Accessed 23 April 2020].

Ristic M.R., Selakovic M., Qureshi T.M.,2017. Employee Motivation Strategies And Creation of Supportive Work Environment In Societies of Post-Socialist Transformation. Polish Journal of Management Studies. [online] 15(2). Available at: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318209618_Employee_motivation_strategies_and_creation_of_supportive_work_environment_in_societies_of_post-socialist_transformation > [Accessed 30 May 2020].

Sabir, A., 2017. Motivation: Outstanding Way to Promote Productivity in Employees. American Journal of Management Science and Engineering. [online] 2(3), p.40. Available at:<https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321652296_Motivation_Outstanding_Way_to_Promote_Productivity_in_Employees> [Accessed 30 May 2020].

Uzonna, U., 2013. Impact of motivation on employees‟ performance: A case study of CreditWest Bank Cyprus. Journal of Economics and International Finance, [online] 5(5). Available at: <https://academicjournals.org/app/webroot/article/article1380794547_Ukaejiofo.pdf> [Accessed 29 May 2020].

Zendage, H., 2018. DOUGLAS MCGREGOR THEORY X AND Y. Scholarly Research Journal for Humanity Science & English Language, [online] 6(26), p.7643. Available at: <http://oaji.net/articles/2017/1201-1529749187.pdf> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Motivational Techniques


Motivating employees is a critical management task, as motivation converts employees' knowledge, skills, and abilities into effort and performance by defining the direction, strength, and duration of work-related behavior (Robnagel, 2016). Therefore understanding exact motivation factors by obtaining creative rewards, recognition, and formulating a low-cost rewards system is crucial (Fosu, 2016). The below video better explains the range of motivational techniques that can be used to improve productivity, reduce workplace stress, and increase self-confidence.

                                           Video 1 – 5 Strategies for Motivating Employees

       

                                                                     (Crampton, 2016)


The strategies contain,

Getting real about compensation -  an effective motivating factor for most employees but up to a certain extent and after no longer motivate. A study conducted by Princeton economist Angus Deaton and psychologist Daniel Kahneman demonstrated that money doesn’t contribute an individual happiness above $ 75,000 (Murphy, 2020). This compensation can be in the form of wages, piecework, or any other incentive pay, bonuses, stock options, company-paid insurance, or any of the other things that may be given to people for performance. And it could also mean status or power. For some people, the money will always be of the utmost importance, while for others it may never be (Uzonna, 2013). 

About a survey stated in Nguyens Theseus, which conducts participating in students studying at Vaasa University of Applied Sciences, financial benefits ranked first, therefore, money becomes an important non-rivalry. People work to earn money and consumption it as a means to protect their lives and fulfill their needs (Nguyen, 2017). As for my experience in the semi-government sector, employees are entitled to a reasonable salary, allowances such as lunch, cost of living, medical scheme, fuel, telephone, monthly Incentive payment, annual leave payment, and annual bonus which employees are highly appreciate something more than money.

Recognize the individual – one of the most accepted clarity towards motivation. This helps employees feel valued and build loyalty. Every employee responds differently to recognition hence needs to identify the individuals in forms of public praise, private recognition, feedback, career planning, bragging of their families, and individual recognition. As for Uzonna, 2013, every employee has unlike desires and important to treat them separately allows for individualizing goals, levels of involvement, and rewards to align with individual needs. Elements such as accomplishment, recognition, accountability, and upgrading are identified as significant motivational factors (Singh, 2017).

For an example, appreciating workers who involved in several extra-curricular activities such as sports, dancing, arts, and drama, create extra value for them among other staffs, credit employees and promote/reward them based on their overall performance, facilitating annual trips and get together belong with families are helping to improve the faithfulness of employees towards the board that I working for.

Establish realistic goals – Employees work on goals when achieving organization objectives. And recognizing the achievement is more appreciable. But a more realistic way is to set individual goals for teams. In other words, placing targets to work towards. Thrashing targets increase determination and self-confidence but those who regularly under perform will end up feeling demoralized (Uzonna, 2013). 

Jason Rhode, CEO of Cirrus, trusts that "morale and motivation in the workplace come from having a significant and sensible objective, a fair plan to achieve the objective, and being able to measure an individual’s performance on the plan. Further, Wallace E. Boston, CEO of American Public University Systems comments, "Create a task that everyone can communicate to and gathering around thus strengthen that task with activities from the top down. Be steady, through good times and bad. These two companies successfully communicated their objectives and task to the entire employees while improved motivation (Anon, 2020).  Apart from above, management set individual targets based on employees' grade/position and delegated work based on employees' performance and capacity by the aim of achieving the organization's objective of the semi-government sector.

Embrace failure – as for the presenter, experiencing passed Fallieres leads to fear of failure. Admit failures as a necessary part of leaning helps overawed fear and come up with new ideas, creative thinking, and solving problems. By welcome defending opinions, complex decision making and taking risk encourages motivation. And it drives to personal growth. 

A survey that conducts participating of students studying at Vaasa University of Applied Sciences clearly shows the growth itself does not mean only the rise in wage or position upgrading; it also includes a taking chance for prospects, to encounter themselves, to gain knowledge, and to absorb new things (Nguyen, 2017). From the viewpoint of the government/semi-government sector, this sounds like many strangers because employees addicted to one set-up from an earlier period hence they are resistant to change it. But now qualified young employees themselves actively involved in change the routine system with their new thinking.

Focus on employee well-being – this includes 5 subcategories namely Purpose that employees feel and know that they make difference, Social which means that they do comforts higher commitment, Financial that an employee earns an equitable wage, Community includes six principles shorten the name as TIGERS (Trust, Interdependence, Genuineness, Empathy, Risk, Success) keep community stronger and Physical relate to removing the stress of work through physical barriers. In other words, creating challenging jobs, good interpersonal relationships, a healthy working environment, active participation, maintain a proper work-life balance also describes the above categories (Re'em, 2010).

For example, flexible working hours, work independence, allow risk-taking, educational assistance to encourage learning support to increase employee motivation.  From my viewpoint, once it feels a blessing and once it feels like a curse that is being in a semi-government sector because most employees can experience both black and white sides of the organization during his/her service period with the time changed.

Apart to above mentioned, enhanced communication, Training, team building, job enrichment, checking system for equity may cause motivate employees at work (Uzonna, 2013).  However, it does not sense that makes them stay in their job. Motivation can origin in excelling performance, but it is the feeling of contentment and happiness that makes employees continue in their existing positions (Nguyen, 2017).


Reference

Anon, 2020. The Top 5 Methods for Motivating Your Employees.  Available at: <https://www.universalclass.com/articles/business/top-5-methods-for-motivating-your-employees.htm> [Accessed 29 May 2020].

Crampton, D., 2016. Motivating Employees: 5 Strategies For Motivating Employees. [video] Available at: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kBSVYt18vkY> [Accessed 29 May 2020].

Fosu, F., 2016. The Impact Of Motivation, On Employee's Performance; The Case Of Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (Kath). Master ofBusiness Administrtion. Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology.

Murphy, 2020.  22 Freakishly Effective Ways to Motivate Employees.  Available at: <https://snacknation.com/blog/how-to-motivate-employees/> [Accessed 23 April 2020].


Nguyen, M., 2017. The Impact Of Employees Motivation On Organizational Effectiveness. VAASAN AMMATTIKORKEAKOULU UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED SCIENCES.

Re’em, Y., 2010. Motivating Public Sector Employees. [Online] (2). Available at: <https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/d364/8f7a3d4021ea00a92cf5f2d2f9cdcb643ca7.pdf> [Accessed 23 April 2020].

Robnagel, C. S., 2016. Leadership and Motivation. In: J. Marques & S. Dhiman, eds. Leadership Today: Practices for Personal and Professional Performance. S.l.: Springer Texts in Business and Economics

Singh, A., 2017. Employee Motivation: A Study on Modern Workplace Motivation. International Journal of Engineering Sciences & Management Research, [online] 4(4). Available at: <https://www.academia.edu/32407094/EMPLOYEE_MOTIVATION_A_STUDY_ON_MODERN_WORKPLACE_MOTIVATION> [Accessed 29 May 2020].

Uzonna, U., 2013. Impact of motivation on employees‟ performance: A case study of CreditWest Bank Cyprus. Journal of Economics and International Finance, [online] 5(5). Available at: <https://academicjournals.org/app/webroot/article/article1380794547_Ukaejiofo.pdf> [Accessed 29 May 2020].

Friday, May 29, 2020

ERG Theory



ERG Theory of needs suggested by Clayton Alderfer and principle is to form a rapport between human needs in an organizational setting. The name ‘ERG’ stands for the three needs that Alderfer identifies in his theory namely Existence, Relatedness, and Growth (Kamau, 2015). Figure 1 below bests describes how the three are related.

       Figure 1 – Relationship of needs
     
                                                                      (Render, 2019)

Alderfer’s theory of motivation is an extension of Maslow’s need theory and takes the premise of need categories a bit further. He perceives that courtesy gets down when lower needs are satisfied, while more consideration of higher needs. Also, he observed that a phenomenon that he called the frustration-regression process where an individual may retreat to lower needs when  upper-level needs are frustrated continually (Souders, 2020). Therefore, Alderfer's theory slightly differs from Maslow's theory as there is no rigid hierarchy of needs (Govindaraju, 2018). This is exclusively significant when it comes to motivating employees (Souders, 2020).

Alderfer proposes three categories of needs known as existence, relatedness, and growth, in which existence complies with Maslow’s basic and security needs. And relatedness involves love and interrelationship that similar to Maslow's belongingness need. Growth needs those related to individuals prospective comparable with Maslow’s Esteem and Self-actualize need (Reagan, 2009).

A survey conducted by Yang, Hwang, and Chen, (2011) on the usage of mobile value-added services in Taiwan provides some significant and experiential statistics using ERG Theory. Research's first attempt is to identify the consumers’ range of value-added services based on their needs and desires. As proven in the study, many of the existing services address the need for growth of the users hence service providers can pass better differentiate its offering. As predicted by the theory, fulfillment of service leads to a greater aspiration for services that address either the same or higher-order requirement allowing marketers to cross-promote their offerings. Contrary to the theory, thwarting with a service does not lead to an upper desire for services that address either the same need or lower demand needs suggest that mobile value-added services not interchangeable thus clear introduction is essential. Mobile value-added services are extremely personal services. Therefore, they require a close focus on technology as well as consumer needs during the development of the services.

The research exposes the basic needs recommended by ERG theory; Existence such as emergency rescue service/roadside service/medical service, transaction/shopping service, mobile shopping, mobile stock trading, electronic wallet, personal finance/investment, mobile banking. While, mobile telecom service, SMS, E-mails, news, chatting, mobile entertainment services, psychological tests, mobile games, multimedia fell into Relatedness. And Growth needs include mobile information service, mobile assistant, online learning, mobile dictionary, job information, online translation, training information, and E-books.

As shown in this research however, not all services in a similar need group are identical. For example, for existence needs, we further divided into emergency rescue services and property management services. The same division of services referring to relatedness needs also. Therefore, no exact order thus, more services offered, more sub-categories may develop. Likewise researchers accept that it is possible of some services can collapse into more than one group. Popular social networking websites such as Facebook and LinkedIn oblige to relatedness. However, they can also be used for career development purposes, and hence, satisfying the growing need. It is feasible that some mobile value-added services can also fulfill more than one need.

Finally, ERG theory can apply as a concept to understand the core perceptions of human behavior and the factors which drive individual motivation (Dunlop, 2018).

References

Dunlop, M., 2018. The Synergy between Psychology and Business: A Case Study on Interdisciplinary Faculty Collaboration. International Journal of Business and Applied Social Science, [online] 4(6). Available at: <https://ijbassnet.com/storage/app/publications/5b372568490c011530340712.pdf> [Accessed 25 May 2020].

Govindaraju, N., 2018. The role of traditional Motivation theories on employee retention. International Journal of Arts, Humanities and Management Studies, [online] 4(6), p.97. Available at: <http://ijahms.com/upcomingissue/12.06.2018.pdf> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Kamau, F., 2015. Enhancing Job Motivation to Improve Employee Performance. Degree program. Vaasan Ammattikorkeakoulu University of Applied Sciences.

Reagan, J., 2009. The Individual and the Organization. [online] Available at: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/262728399_The_Individual_and_the_Organization> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Render, J., 2019. Alderfer’s ERG Motivational Theory. [image] Available at: <https://agile-mercurial.com/2019/08/27/alderfers-erg-theory-of-motivation/> [Accessed 25 May 2020].

Souders, B., 2020. 20 Most Popular Theories of Motivation in Psychology. [online] PositivePsychology.com. Available at: <https://positivepsychology.com/motivation-theories-psychology/> [Accessed 22 May 2020].

Yang, C., Hwang, M. and Chen, Y., 2011. An empirical study of the existence, relatedness, and growth (ERG) theory in consumer’s selection of mobile value-added services. African Journal of Business Management, [online] 5(19). Available at: <http://www.academicjournals.org/AJBM> [Accessed 25 May 2020].

Theory X and Theory Y


   Image 1 – Theory X and Theory 

             (Hattangadi, 2015)

The management style of every manager should inspirit on their assumptions and believes origin to adopt a way to treat and motivate employees (Hattangadi, 2015). Douglas McGregor suggested that two theories called theory X and Y to describe employee motivation and the effects of that (Souders, 2020).

Theory X

As for the McGregor, employees who avoid work and not like to take are known as theory X (Souders, 2020). Also employees tend to discharge from the responsibility whenever they can. Therefore managers suppose that these people need close supervision and all-inclusive control systems have to be cultivated. Theory X is based on suspicion on employees and it styles around highly limited supervision, and a corrective atmosphere. It drives to autocratic leadership (Hattangadi, 2015). However in most cases this theory exposed as redundant and unreliable with present business needs for continuous improvement of organizational performance. Even though, the position of  Theory  X remains an essential approach to management,  contributes to favorable impacts in organizations,  and may still dominate in certain industries or geographical area (Arslan and Staub, 2013).

Theory Y

Employees who enjoy work and use strength when they have switched into the workplace are known as theory Y (Souders, 2020). The management's key duty is to motivate employees and exploit obligations. This theory assist to adopt participative leaders: also known as democratic leaders. Who assumes that employees are committed to organizational objectives (Hattangadi, 2015). Theory Y management direction positively linked with job satisfaction but not linked with job performance (Kopelman, Prottas and Davis, 2008).

McGregor recognized some organizational practices consistent with his theory Y assumptions such as participative leadership, delegation, job enlargement, and performance appraisal. But McGregor identified that implementation of these practices in theory X mindset is much effective and employees seeing such observes are deceitful guidance (Kopelman, Prottas and Davis, 2008).

According to Arslan and Staub (2013), theory Y leadership may have progressive inspiration on organizational performance but no direct indication related to the firm's performance criteria. Thus above study evidence that the leadership styles led by theory Y management of smaller medium enterprises will ensure the toughness of the organizational performance such as increasing turnover, making innovations, and decreasing overall costs.



Theory into practice

Abraham Maslow perceived Douglas McGregor as a mentor. He was a strong follower of Theories X and Y, and he put Theory Y people who want to work, achieve, and take responsibility, into practice in a Californian electronics factory. However, Maslow found that an organization compelled solely by Theory Y could not succeed, as some sense of direction and formation was necessary. Instead, Maslow promoted an upgraded version of Theory Y which involved an element of structured security and direction taken from Theory X (Douglas McGregor: Theory X and Theory Y, 2015).

Maslow's negative experience with implementing Theory Y must be balanced against that of McGregor himself at introducing theory Y in Procter & Gamble plant in Georgia, through the concept of self-directed teams. This plant was found to be a third more profitable than any other Procter and Gamble plant; it was kept a trade secret until the mid-1990s (Douglas McGregor: Theory X and Theory Y, 2015).

According to the research done in the banking sector of Bangladesh, identified theory Y seems more applicable rather theory X for the banking industry. Hence, the job is well structured and well-disciplined that ensure an environment suitable for the employees to show the assumption of theory Y through their performance and characteristics. Further, employees indicate their analytical ability by creativeness and initiative in problem-solving, employees are self-controlled and self-directed, do not avoid responsibility since of high payment and all are accountable for supervisors, committed to objectives against assign rewards for achievements. Moreover, selecting employees who are highly qualified, energetic, and hard-working with entrepreneurial sprite, and seem to like work inherently, who are driven to succeed in a highly competitive and challenging environment illustrating their solid recruitment process (Islam and Eva, 2017).

Though these theories are very basic, they offered a platform for future generations of management philosophers and specialists to understand the changing dynamics of human behavior (Zendage, 2018). Taken too literally, Theories X and Y signify idealistic extremes. Most employees including managers' fall somewhere in between these poles. Recent studies have questioned the strictness of the model, yet McGregor's X-Y Theories remain guiding principles to the management to evolve processes which help in organizational development. A mix of practices that make sure a good balance of systems and the independence to execute at the workplace is likely to motivate the employees more (Bhatia, 2020).


References


Arslan, A. and Staub, S., 2013. Theory X and Theory Y Type Leadership Behavior and its Impact on Organizational Performance: Small Business owners in the Sishen Lighting and Chandelier Distric. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, [online] 75(102). Available at: <https://reader.elsevier.com/reader/sd/pii/S187704281300548X?token=EF517325C4AFD528164506D7CB24EB05D45A801DB3D4C6FD5AF68ABA4327535A4BD5E0E5600B640AE79B61D1F1CB557D> [Accessed 23 May 2020].

Bhatia, G., 2020. Theory X and Theory Y : Theories of employee Motivation. [Blog] empxtrack.com, Available at: <https://empxtrack.com/blog/theory-x-and-theory-y-theories-of-employee-motivation/> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

 Douglas Mcgregor :Theory X And Theory Y, 2015. [ebook] Northants: Charted Management Institute. Available at: <https://switcheducation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/SEB_LYO_McGregor_Thinker.pdf> [Accessed 23 May 2020].
Hattangadi, V., 2015. Theory X & Theory Y. International Journal of Recent Research Aspects, [online] 2(4), pp.20-21. Available at: <https://www.academia.edu/28189306/Theory_X_and_Theory_Y> [Accessed 23 May 2020].

Islam, M. and Eva, S., 2017. Application of Mcgregor’s Theory X and Theory Y: Perception of Management toward the Employees in the Banking Industry of Bangladesh. The International Journal of Business & Management, [online] 5(11), p.141. Available at: <http://internationaljournalcorner.com/index.php/theijbm/article/view/125587/86592> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Kopelman, R., Prottas, D. and Davis, A., 2008. Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Y: Toward a Construct-valid Measure*. JOURNAL OF MANAGERIAL ISSUES, xx(2).

Souders, B., 2020. 20 Most Popular Theories Of Motivation In Psychology. [online] PositivePsychology.com. Available at: <https://positivepsychology.com/motivation-theories-psychology/> [Accessed 22 May 2020].

Zendage, H., 2018. DOUGLAS MCGREGOR THEORY X AND Y. Scholarly Research Journal for Humanity Science & English Language, [online] 6(26), p.7643. Available at: <http://oaji.net/articles/2017/1201-1529749187.pdf> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Thursday, May 21, 2020

Herzberg's Motivation- Hygiene Theory



Herzberg‘s Motivation-Hygiene theory, also known as the Two-factor theory that defining the rationale of the job which human beings into (M. Badubi, 2017). Herzberg‘s effort was not straight away to motivation but to identify the employee motivation factors which influence job satisfaction and dissatisfaction (Beardwell, Holden and Claydon, 2004). The absence of these does not affect dissatisfaction also motivation either (Nguyen, 2017).

 Image 1 – Herzberg’s two - factor theory

       (Nguyen, 2017)


Motivating factors comprising of recognition, achievement, work itself, responsibility, advancement, and growth are known as intrinsic factors that are intangible and contract with sensitive needs (Nguyen, 2017). These relate to what a person does at work, which really contributes to employees' level of job satisfaction (Yusoff, Kian and Idris, 2013). Moreover, identify as job content factors that are environmental (Riley, 2005).

Hygiene factors that known as job context elements include supervision, company policy, relationship with supervisor, working conditions, salary, relationship with peers and subordinates, personal life, status, and security (Riley, 2005). According to the theory, these extrinsic factors do not belong to employees’ motivation were just to prevent any dissatisfaction in their workplace (Yusoff, Kian and Idris, 2013). The theory suggests that motivators are the most powerful influencer of job satisfaction rather hygiene factors become more powerful in Job dissatisfactory (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017).

As said by Asst. Prof. Dr. Renata Borges, a comparative study on job satisfaction among 670 professionals from the public and private sector, found that the overall level of job satisfaction is significantly higher in the public sector than in the private sector (Busatlic and Mujabasic, 2018).

As my experience of working in a semi-government organization, the management put great effort to eliminate job dissatisfaction and create conditions for job satisfaction. For consider hygiene factors, as general all employees are faced with a high cost of living and sometimes unfavorable economic conditions. Often challenging economic conditions and the expectations by society (family members) from workers have made money a big issue in the labor front. One cannot be wrong in suggesting that the worker becomes dissatisfied when commensurate pay is not received for work done. This is typical of a hygiene factor in Fredrick Herzberg’s two-factor theory of motivation. Another issue that affects the employee is job security, an example of the hygiene factor. Employees would normally do everything possible to secure their jobs. Therefore job security means survival to most employees. Furthermore, there is generally the perception that most employees prefer working in the public sector than the private. This is not coincidental because most workers hold the view that in the private sector lifelong work is not guaranteed which therefore becomes a threat to job security.

Money and job security are two key factors in Frederick Herzberg’s two-factor theory and looking at my organizational experience, it is quite reasonable to suggest that above two hygiene factors play a major role in motivating government employees. It is however worth emphasizing that employees are more concerned with wages and job security. Hence they may not be the dominant motivator in the government and semi-government situation. However, factors such as pleasant working environment, company policy, keen supervision, clear relationship with supervisors, sound relationship with peers, fair relationship with a subordinate, balance of personal life, acceptable status comply with the theory.

With referred to motivating factor work itself, rewarding are job content rather tying performance and salary increases to work outputs may be one of the ways to encouraging commitment and advancing organizations' aspirations, but in the government sector, all employees have a general platform of salary increments and bonuses which vary from their category. Also the appraisals may be a bias that subjects to the immediate supervisor. Hence it is worthwhile to suggest that some of these motivators do not comply with the theory. Furthermore, workers are motivated not only by the financial rewards but also by the recognition that they get from their managers. Additionally, the government and semi-government employees can be motivated through building effective and efficient work groups where organizational goals are personalized for departments and emphasis placed on the importance of each department in the overall performance of the organizations. Additionally avoiding micromanaging, ensuring fairness in pay structures, promotions and, work allocations and eschewing favoritism, nepotism, and cronyism by managers would be essential to addressing employee motivation issues in both government and semi-government sector.

As Herzberg explained in his theory, it does not take only the motivators factors to motivate employees neither does it take the hygiene factors to remove dissatisfaction. To motivate and satisfy employees, managers need to effectively blend the factors well to suit the special needs of their employees (Dartey-Baah and Amoako, 2011).

References

Alshmemri, M., Shahwan-Akl, L. and Maude, P., 2017. Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory. Life Science Journal, [online] 14(5). Available at: <https://www.lifesciencesite.com/lsj/life140517/03_32120lsj140517_12_16.pdf> [Accessed 18 May 2020].

Busatlic, S. and Mujabasic, A., 2018. HERZBERG’S TWO-FACTOR THEORY OF JOB SATISFACTION – COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN PRIVATE AND PUBLIC HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS IN CANTON SARAJEVO. The International Journal of Business and Management Research, [online] 8(6). Available at: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329417051> [Accessed 18 May 2020].

Dartey-Baah, K. and Amoako, G., 2011. Application of Frederick Herzberg’s Two -Factor theory inassessing and understanding employee motivation at work: aGhanaian Perspective. European Journal of Business and Management, [online] 3(9). Available at: <https://www.academia.edu/29358885/Application_of_Frederick_Herzbergs_Two-Factor_theory_in_assessing_and_understanding_employee_motivation_at_work_a_Ghanaian_Perspective> [Accessed 20 May 2020].

M. Badubi, R., 2017. Theories of Motivation and Their Application in Organizations: A Risk Analysis. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INNOVATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, [online] 3(3), pp.44-51. Available at: <https://researchleap.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/04.-Theories-of-Motivation-and-their-Application-in-Organisations-A-Risk-Analysis.pdf> [Accessed 17 May 2020].

Nguyen, M., 2017. The Impact Of Employees Motivation On Organizational Effectiveness. VAASAN AMMATTIKORKEAKOULU UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED SCIENCES.

Riley, S., 2005. Herzberg 'S Two-Factor Theory Of Motivation Applied To The Motivational Techniques Within Financial Institutions. Honors Program. Eastern Michigan University.

Yusoff, W., Kian, T. and Idris, M., 2013. Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory on Work Motivation: Does it Works for Todays Environment?. Global Journal of Commerce & Management Perspective, [online] 2(5). Available at: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/262639924_Herzberg's_Two-Factor_Theory_on_Work_Motivation_Does_it_Works_for_Todays_Environment> [Accessed 17 May 2020].

Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Theory


Maslow's hierarchy of needs is a motivational theory in psychology comprising a five-tier model of human needs, often depicted as hierarchical levels within a pyramid (McLeod, 2018). These needs can create internal pressures that can influence an individual’s behavior (Hartzell, 2012).

        Image 1 – Maslow’s hierarchy of needs pyramid

        (McLeod, 2018)

      Five tiers of need theory can explain as below.
  1.  Physiological needs – which known as basic necessities of being existence such as air, food, drink, shelter, clothing, warmth, sex, sleep. Until satisfying these requirements become most significant than other needs since physiological needs perform as subsistence of a human body (McLeod, 2018). By providing comfortable working conditions, reasonable work hours, and the necessary breaks to use the bathroom and eat and/or drink can show the appliance of this theory for employees (Hartzell, 2012).                                                                                                                              
  2. Safety/Security needs – this includes individuals’ impression of secure within the society and protected against violence. The need for safety is revealed with job security, savings and for insurances of health, mental health, old age and disability (Haque, Haque and Islam, 2014). An employer/manager can explain this needs by offering safe working conditions, secure compensation (such as a salary), and job security, which is especially important in a bad economy (Hartzell, 2012).                       
  3. Love and belongingness/Social needs –discuss the interpersonal relationships inspires behavior examples to include friendship, intimacy, trust, and acceptance, receiving and giving affection and love. Affiliating, being part of a group in a family, within friends and work. Also important to humans so that they do not feel alone, isolated, and depressed (McLeod, 2018). As a manager, you can account for the social needs of your employees by making sure each of your employees knows one another, encouraging cooperative teamwork, being an accessible and kind supervisor, and promoting a good work-life balance (Hartzell, 2012).                                                  
  4. Esteem needs - which classified into two categories under Maslow: (i) esteem for    oneself (dignity, achievement, mastery, and independence) and (ii) the desire for reputation or respect from others such as status, prestige (McLeod, 2018). Employees willing to evaluate themselves highly and appreciation from other people based on their achievement receive. Lack of these needs may cause inferiority, helplessness and weakness (Haque, Haque and Islam, 2014).  Organizations can use esteem needs of your employees by offering praise and recognition when the employee does well, and offering promotions and additional responsibility to reflect your belief that they are a valued employee for the organization (Hartzell, 2012).                                     
  5. Self-actualization needs - realizing personal potential, self-fulfillment, seeking personal growth, and peak experiences. A desire "to become everything one is capable of becoming” (McLeod, 2018).  By providing challenging work, inviting employees to participate in decision-making, and giving them flexibility and autonomy in their jobs Self-actualization needs could be used in an organization (Hartzell, 2012).

The theory is based on a simple evidence which human beings have needs that are hierarchically ranked (Maslow, 2018). Also try to explain the job satisfaction of employees (M. Badubi, 2017). Most individuals encourage and motivated by their personal desire, wants and goals (Nguyen, 2017). Mark, 2019, stated that lower-level needs must be met before higher-level needs. The deficit principle claims that once a need is satisfied, it is no longer a motivator because an individual will take action only to satisfy unmet needs (Hartzell, 2012).

I am working for a leading semi-government organization in Sri Lanka. By considering the first step of need theory, In general, employees can fulfill their basic needs by obtaining a sensible salary which makes sense of financial independence that comes along with. Incentives, and bonuses that vary between individuals positions in the organizational hierarchy enhance the motivation of employees. Further, receiving uniforms, filing bag reimbursements, and food allowance help to satisfy the basic needs.

Since this is a semi-government organization job security is comparatively higher than the private sector. Likewise, introducing routing and hospitalization medical reimbursement schemes tends to secure employees' health by meeting the safety needs. 

Facilitating low-interest loan schemes for houses or lands, vehicles, bicycles, three-wheeler, for weddings, buy furniture, buy jewelry, funerals and special distresses can help employees to uplift their family living standards. Apart from these loans employees may elect to request special loans, special advances for low-interest rate, and festival loans and festival advances without interest at festival season. Fuel allowances, and telephone bill reimbursements which vary between individuals positions are some methods used to fulfill social needs.

Additionally, get-together, Awurudu festival functions, and cultural shows are support employees being part of the group and overcome depression. Further, recognizing hard work, rewording them, and upgrading on time make confident themselves.

Management hierarchy from bottom to top each employee is individually accountable for the work they do which enables them to participate in the decision making process up to some extent. Besides, create a flexible, dependable working environment for employees by satisfying the last step of need theory.  

This theory provided useful insights and advises for managers and leaders such as managers to motivate employees by devising programs or practices towards satisfying emerging or unmet needs. Also this gain for organization to implement support programs and focus groups taking the time to understand the needs of the respective employees to help employees deal with stress, especially during more challenging times (Kreitner and Kinicki, 1998).


References

Hartzell, S., 2012. The Needs Theory: Motivating Employees with Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs.

Haque, M., Haque, M. and Islam, M., 2014. Motivational Theories - A Critical Analysis. 68, p.63.

Kreitner, R. and Kinicki, A., 1998. Organizational Behavior. 4th ed. Irwin/McGraw-Hill, 1998, p.670.

Maslow, A., 2018. A Theory of Human Motivation. [Place of publication not identified]: Wilder Publications, Inc.

Mark, 2019. 5 Psychological Theories of Motivation to Increase Productivity. [Blog] contactzilla, Available at: <https://contactzilla.com/blog/5-psychological-theories-motivation-increase-productivity/> [Accessed 15 May 2020].

McLeod, S., 2018. Simply Psychology. Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, [online] Available at: <https://www.simplypsychology.org/maslow.html> [Accessed 10 May 2020].

M. Badubi, R., 2017. Theories of Motivation and Their Application in Organizations: A Risk Analysis. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INNOVATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, [online] 3(3), pp.44-51. Available at: <https://researchleap.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/04.-Theories-of-Motivation-and-their-Application-in-Organisations-A-Risk-Analysis.pdf> [Accessed 17 May 2020].

Nguyen, M., 2017. The Impact of Employees Motivation on Organizational Effectiveness. VAASAN AMMATTIKORKEAKOULU UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED SCIENCES.