Friday, May 29, 2020

Theory X and Theory Y


   Image 1 – Theory X and Theory 

             (Hattangadi, 2015)

The management style of every manager should inspirit on their assumptions and believes origin to adopt a way to treat and motivate employees (Hattangadi, 2015). Douglas McGregor suggested that two theories called theory X and Y to describe employee motivation and the effects of that (Souders, 2020).

Theory X

As for the McGregor, employees who avoid work and not like to take are known as theory X (Souders, 2020). Also employees tend to discharge from the responsibility whenever they can. Therefore managers suppose that these people need close supervision and all-inclusive control systems have to be cultivated. Theory X is based on suspicion on employees and it styles around highly limited supervision, and a corrective atmosphere. It drives to autocratic leadership (Hattangadi, 2015). However in most cases this theory exposed as redundant and unreliable with present business needs for continuous improvement of organizational performance. Even though, the position of  Theory  X remains an essential approach to management,  contributes to favorable impacts in organizations,  and may still dominate in certain industries or geographical area (Arslan and Staub, 2013).

Theory Y

Employees who enjoy work and use strength when they have switched into the workplace are known as theory Y (Souders, 2020). The management's key duty is to motivate employees and exploit obligations. This theory assist to adopt participative leaders: also known as democratic leaders. Who assumes that employees are committed to organizational objectives (Hattangadi, 2015). Theory Y management direction positively linked with job satisfaction but not linked with job performance (Kopelman, Prottas and Davis, 2008).

McGregor recognized some organizational practices consistent with his theory Y assumptions such as participative leadership, delegation, job enlargement, and performance appraisal. But McGregor identified that implementation of these practices in theory X mindset is much effective and employees seeing such observes are deceitful guidance (Kopelman, Prottas and Davis, 2008).

According to Arslan and Staub (2013), theory Y leadership may have progressive inspiration on organizational performance but no direct indication related to the firm's performance criteria. Thus above study evidence that the leadership styles led by theory Y management of smaller medium enterprises will ensure the toughness of the organizational performance such as increasing turnover, making innovations, and decreasing overall costs.



Theory into practice

Abraham Maslow perceived Douglas McGregor as a mentor. He was a strong follower of Theories X and Y, and he put Theory Y people who want to work, achieve, and take responsibility, into practice in a Californian electronics factory. However, Maslow found that an organization compelled solely by Theory Y could not succeed, as some sense of direction and formation was necessary. Instead, Maslow promoted an upgraded version of Theory Y which involved an element of structured security and direction taken from Theory X (Douglas McGregor: Theory X and Theory Y, 2015).

Maslow's negative experience with implementing Theory Y must be balanced against that of McGregor himself at introducing theory Y in Procter & Gamble plant in Georgia, through the concept of self-directed teams. This plant was found to be a third more profitable than any other Procter and Gamble plant; it was kept a trade secret until the mid-1990s (Douglas McGregor: Theory X and Theory Y, 2015).

According to the research done in the banking sector of Bangladesh, identified theory Y seems more applicable rather theory X for the banking industry. Hence, the job is well structured and well-disciplined that ensure an environment suitable for the employees to show the assumption of theory Y through their performance and characteristics. Further, employees indicate their analytical ability by creativeness and initiative in problem-solving, employees are self-controlled and self-directed, do not avoid responsibility since of high payment and all are accountable for supervisors, committed to objectives against assign rewards for achievements. Moreover, selecting employees who are highly qualified, energetic, and hard-working with entrepreneurial sprite, and seem to like work inherently, who are driven to succeed in a highly competitive and challenging environment illustrating their solid recruitment process (Islam and Eva, 2017).

Though these theories are very basic, they offered a platform for future generations of management philosophers and specialists to understand the changing dynamics of human behavior (Zendage, 2018). Taken too literally, Theories X and Y signify idealistic extremes. Most employees including managers' fall somewhere in between these poles. Recent studies have questioned the strictness of the model, yet McGregor's X-Y Theories remain guiding principles to the management to evolve processes which help in organizational development. A mix of practices that make sure a good balance of systems and the independence to execute at the workplace is likely to motivate the employees more (Bhatia, 2020).


References


Arslan, A. and Staub, S., 2013. Theory X and Theory Y Type Leadership Behavior and its Impact on Organizational Performance: Small Business owners in the Sishen Lighting and Chandelier Distric. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, [online] 75(102). Available at: <https://reader.elsevier.com/reader/sd/pii/S187704281300548X?token=EF517325C4AFD528164506D7CB24EB05D45A801DB3D4C6FD5AF68ABA4327535A4BD5E0E5600B640AE79B61D1F1CB557D> [Accessed 23 May 2020].

Bhatia, G., 2020. Theory X and Theory Y : Theories of employee Motivation. [Blog] empxtrack.com, Available at: <https://empxtrack.com/blog/theory-x-and-theory-y-theories-of-employee-motivation/> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

 Douglas Mcgregor :Theory X And Theory Y, 2015. [ebook] Northants: Charted Management Institute. Available at: <https://switcheducation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/SEB_LYO_McGregor_Thinker.pdf> [Accessed 23 May 2020].
Hattangadi, V., 2015. Theory X & Theory Y. International Journal of Recent Research Aspects, [online] 2(4), pp.20-21. Available at: <https://www.academia.edu/28189306/Theory_X_and_Theory_Y> [Accessed 23 May 2020].

Islam, M. and Eva, S., 2017. Application of Mcgregor’s Theory X and Theory Y: Perception of Management toward the Employees in the Banking Industry of Bangladesh. The International Journal of Business & Management, [online] 5(11), p.141. Available at: <http://internationaljournalcorner.com/index.php/theijbm/article/view/125587/86592> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

Kopelman, R., Prottas, D. and Davis, A., 2008. Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Y: Toward a Construct-valid Measure*. JOURNAL OF MANAGERIAL ISSUES, xx(2).

Souders, B., 2020. 20 Most Popular Theories Of Motivation In Psychology. [online] PositivePsychology.com. Available at: <https://positivepsychology.com/motivation-theories-psychology/> [Accessed 22 May 2020].

Zendage, H., 2018. DOUGLAS MCGREGOR THEORY X AND Y. Scholarly Research Journal for Humanity Science & English Language, [online] 6(26), p.7643. Available at: <http://oaji.net/articles/2017/1201-1529749187.pdf> [Accessed 24 May 2020].

2 comments:

  1. In addition to your views, it’s essential that management needs to get involved in the organizational decision making process in order to utilize the skills and abilities of employees, if the organization employs Theory X type of employees (Lawter et al, 2015).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for the comment.
      Generally, Theory X style managers believe their employees are
      less intelligent than the managers are, lazier than the managers are, or work solely for a sustainable income. Due to these assumptions, Theory X concludes the average workforce is
      more efficient under strict supervision and authoritarian approach to management (Aithal, Kumar, 2016).

      Delete